24/7 Emergency Service Mon-Fri 8am-6pm · Sat 9am-4pm
Heat Pumps · Efficiency

Why Your Heat Pump Costs More to Run Than It Should

Published October 24, 2026 18 min read By BC Home Service Team

A heat pump that has quietly lost 20 or 30 percent of its efficiency does not break. It bills. The house still heats, the thermostat still says 21, and the electricity number climbs month over month for reasons invisible from the living room. This guide is the detective work: how to prove the loss from your BC Hydro bill, the seven causes we actually find in the field, and the fix-versus-payback math for each one.

Technician measuring heat pump efficiency and refrigerant charge on an outdoor unit in Metro Vancouver BC
A heat pump rarely announces its decline. It just starts billing for it.
Chapter 1

The Honest Answer Up Front

When a heat pump costs 20 to 40 percent more to run than it did two winters ago, the cause is almost never mysterious. In the order we actually find them: auxiliary heat running when it should not, a refrigerant charge that has drifted off spec, a dirty outdoor coil, a starving indoor side, defrost cycles that have gone excessive, ducts leaking a fifth of your heat into an attic, and a thermostat strategy imported from the furnace era. Each one is invisible from the couch. The house still reaches 21 degrees. The only symptom is the bill, and by the time most homeowners call, two or three of these causes are stacked on top of each other.

The numbers make this worth chasing. A heat pump that has slipped from a seasonal COP of 3.0 to 2.2 uses about a third more electricity for identical heat. On a typical Metro Vancouver heating season, that is several hundred dollars a year, every year, quietly. The fixes range from free (a thermostat setting) to $149-$250 (the maintenance visit that catches most of the list) to $250-$900 (a refrigerant leak repair), and the audit that identifies which fix applies starts at our $89 diagnostic, credited to any repair. If you are weighing all this against a new cold-climate unit, the heat pump page covers the replacement side; this guide is about the machine you already own and the money it is quietly spending for you.

A heat pump does not usually break. It fades, and it sends the invoice for the fade. That is why the first tool in this guide is your BC Hydro usage history, not a wrench.

~0x the cost

Auxiliary strip heat versus the compressor at COP 3. One locked relay can do this to your whole winter.

0-20% capacity

What a matted outdoor coil costs you in heating capacity, before the extra defrost cycles it triggers are counted.

0-6°C at 90% RH

Metro Vancouver's defrost band, where coastal heat pumps can log hundreds of defrost cycles a season. Each one is unpaid heat loss.

Chapter 2

Reading the Symptom: Usage, Not Dollars

Before anyone touches the equipment, separate rate creep from efficiency loss, because BC Hydro bills both the same way and only one of them is a repair. Log into your account and open the usage history, two to three heating seasons deep. For each winter month, divide kWh by that month's heating degree days, a weather normalization you can pull from Environment Canada records, or approximate honestly by comparing similar-temperature months across years. A flat kWh-per-degree-day line means your machine is holding efficiency and any bill increase is rates and tiers. A line that has climbed 20 percent or more means the system is buying the same warmth with more electricity, and the rest of this guide applies to you.

Two local wrinkles matter. BC Hydro's residential Step 1 and Step 2 rates, roughly 11-12 cents and 14 cents per kWh as of recent years, mean a heat pump that pushes your winter usage over the step threshold gets billed at the higher marginal rate on every kWh above it, so a 20 percent efficiency loss can show up as more than 20 percent on the dollar total. And a mild winter can mask real degradation: fewer degree-days, less usage, a bill that looks "fine" while the machine behind it is running 30 percent rich. The degree-day math is the only version that sees through both.

Gather three more clues while you are in the app. Aux heat runtime, visible on most smart thermostats as auxiliary or emergency heat hours. Defrost frequency, which you can observe as steam and fan-stop episodes at the outdoor unit in the 0-6°C damp. And supply air temperature at a far register on a cold evening, which should run noticeably warm, roughly 30-40°C above room temperature on a healthy system in heating mode. Those three numbers, plus the usage line, are the intake form for everything that follows, and you collected them for free in twenty minutes. The complete heat pump guide covers the buying side of efficiency ratings; this is the owning side.

Chapter 3

Cause 1: Auxiliary Heat, the Silent Bill Killer

Auxiliary strips are resistance heaters bolted into your ductwork as backup, and they are the most expensive way to make heat that exists in your house. The compressor moves heat: at a COP of 3, it delivers three units of warmth per unit of electricity. Strips make heat: one unit in, one unit out, minus nothing for comfort. When strips carry the load, your cost of heat roughly triples, and the tragedy is how quietly it happens. A thermostat left in EM HEAT mode since a cold snap in January. A control board that stages the strips on at a temperature threshold the system no longer respects. A defrost cycle that fires the strips every time. A cold-snap recovery that calls for full auxiliary because the thermostat was set up five degrees in one move.

The arithmetic in BC terms: one kilowatt-hour of strip heat buys about 3,412 BTU. One kilowatt-hour through a healthy heat pump in our climate buys 8,500-10,000 BTU across the season. At a blended 12-13 cents per kWh, heating a typical home through a cold January week on strips can cost $25-$45 a day; the same warmth through the compressor costs $9-$15. A locked-on aux relay discovered in March is routinely a $300-$600 line item on the winter, which is why the aux runtime log is the first thing we read on a high-bill call and why this chapter is first in the causes.

Heat source BTU per kWh Cost of 100,000 BTU at ~12.5¢/kWh Relative cost
Heat pump, COP 3.0 (healthy)~10,240~$1.221.0x — the benchmark
Heat pump, COP 2.2 (degraded)~7,510~$1.661.4x — the fade nobody notices
Auxiliary strip heat~3,412~$3.663.0x — the silent killer
Baseboard, room by room~3,412~$3.663.0x — same physics, familiar form

The fixes span the honesty spectrum: a thermostat mode correction costs nothing and takes ten seconds; a control board or sequencer repair runs $450-$850 installed; and a balance-point review, whether your system switches to strips at a temperature it no longer needs to, is part of the diagnostic conversation. Cold-climate heat pumps installed in the Fraser Valley cold pockets around Langley and Abbotsford deserve a specific look here, because a unit that was commissioned with a conservative lockout setting years ago may be reaching for strips at -2°C when its hardware can carry the house to -10°C or below.

Chapter 4

Cause 2: Refrigerant Charge Off Spec

A heat pump's refrigerant charge is a tuned value, weighed in by the ounce at commissioning, and both directions of drift cost you. Undercharge, the common direction because leaks only go one way, starves the evaporator: capacity drops, the indoor coil runs colder, supply air weakens, and the outdoor coil frosts in patterns it should not. Overcharge, usually the residue of well-meaning top-ups, floods the compressor and slogs the cycle. Industry testing has shown efficiency losses in the 5-20 percent band for charges off by 10-25 percent, and the loss lands directly on the bill because the system compensates with runtime and auxiliary heat.

The homeowner-side symptoms are readable if you know them: runtimes that stretch longer for the same setpoint, ice on the outdoor coil concentrated at the bottom third, supply air that is merely lukewarm on cold mornings, and a system that once held temperature at -5°C now surrendering to the strips. What the symptoms cannot tell you is how much charge is missing, because pressures move with outdoor temperature, and reading them correctly requires the manufacturer's charging chart against measured conditions. That is technician work.

Safety first: Refrigerant work is certified-technician-only in BC, full stop. The new A2L-class refrigerants such as R-454B are mildly flammable and require dedicated handling equipment and procedures; the outdoor unit's capacitor also holds a serious charge with the breaker off. Never open a service valve, never attempt a gauge hookup, and never accept a "top-up" from anyone who cannot produce a refrigerant handling certificate. If your system needs charge every year, it has a leak, and the correct fix is a leak search, a repair, and a weighed-in charge to nameplate, typically $250-$900 depending on access and refrigerant.

One distinction protects your wallet: charge is not a consumable. A system that "just needs a bit every spring" is being slowly strangled, because each top-up masks the leak while the compressor runs progressively off design. We treat every charge loss as a leak until proven otherwise, and the proof is a proper search: pressure test, electronic detection, or UV dye, followed by repair and a documented weigh-in. It costs more than a top-up once, and then it is finished, which is the entire argument of this chapter in one sentence.

Chapter 5

Cause 3: The Outdoor Coil You Cannot See Through

Stand at your outdoor unit and look through the fan grille at the coil fins. On a healthy unit you see daylight and orderly aluminum. On a neglected Metro Vancouver unit you see a felt mat of grey, and that mat is a bill. In heating mode, a fouled coil cannot absorb heat from the air, so capacity drops and runtime climbs. In the damp band below 6°C, it also frosts earlier and heavier, which triggers longer, more frequent defrost cycles, each one briefly reversing the system to cooling and firing the strips. A coil 20 percent blocked commonly costs 10-20 percent in seasonal efficiency once the defrost penalty is counted.

BC loads its coils with enthusiasm. Cottonwood seed flies for two to three weeks every June and felts every horizontal surface in the region, including precisely-spaced coil fins. Western red cedar pollen follows. Lawn mowers throw clippings at exactly unit height. And in Richmond, Delta and along the North Shore, salt air deposits a corrosive film that both insulates the coil and slowly eats the fins themselves, which is why coastal units age differently than valley units; the Richmond heat pump page covers the coastal maintenance rhythm. Snow is the winter version: a unit buried to the top of its coil is recirculating its own cold exhaust, and clearing a snow drift costs nothing compared to what it saves.

The wash-down is homeowner-safe and twice-yearly: power off at the outdoor disconnect, garden hose from the inside out, gentle stream, no pressure washer ever, fifteen minutes, done in May after the cottonwood and again in September before heating season. For felted or corroded coils, a professional cleaning with coil-safe chemistry, $149-$250 as part of a maintenance visit, restores what the hose cannot. While you are at the unit, keep the clearance honest: a foot or more of clear space on the sides, nothing stacked against the cabinet, and the pad level, because a tilted unit pools water in the wrong places and strains its own refrigerant piping.

Chapter 6

Cause 4: The Indoor Side, Starving

Every cause so far lives at the outdoor unit, but the indoor half starves just as quietly. A loaded filter restricts airflow across the indoor coil, and in heating mode that means less air picking up less heat: supply temperature sags, runtimes stretch, and on a ducted system the whole chain pays. A clogged evaporator coil, layered with years of the dust that got past old filters, does the same job more permanently. Closed registers, a return grille blocked by a couch, or a bedroom door held shut against a carpet all choke the loop. The system compensates with time, and time is billed by the kWh.

The homeowner test is the supply-air check from Chapter 2: on a cold evening, hold a hand at a far register. Healthy heat pump supply air in heating mode runs roughly 30-40°C above room temperature, warm enough that you would not call it subtle. Lukewarm, in the "warm bath" range rather than the "hot tap" range, is a system working harder for less, and the filter is the first suspect at $15-$40, the indoor coil the second at $149-$250 in a maintenance visit. If the filter is fresh and the coil is clean and the air is still lukewarm, the charge and the aux staging are next in line, and that is a diagnostic conversation with gauges and meters.

One BC-specific habit earns its own sentence: after a wildfire-smoke summer, change the filter before the first heating week, not after. Smoke particulate is fine enough to load a filter fast and invisible enough that the filter looks cleaner than it is, and a heat pump starting its heating season behind a smoke-loaded filter starts the season in the red. The spring side of the habit lives in the cooling and AC page; the fall side belongs to this paragraph.

Chapter 7

Cause 5: Defrost Cycles That Have Gone Rogue

Metro Vancouver's winter is a defrost stress test. Between 0 and 6°C with humidity in the 90s, an outdoor coil in heating mode runs below freezing and harvests moisture from the air onto its own fins, and the frost has to be removed for the machine to keep absorbing heat. Defrost is a controlled reversal: the system briefly runs as an air conditioner, strips the ice, usually fires the auxiliary strips so the house does not feel it, and switches back. Done correctly, each cycle costs a few minutes of efficiency. Done excessively, it is a slow leak of warm electricity into a cold backyard.

Count the cycles. On a damp January day in this climate, a healthy unit might defrost a handful of times across 24 hours, each cycle 5-10 minutes, announced by the outdoor fan stopping, steam rising, and sometimes a whoosh at switchover. If you are watching the outdoor unit steam every hour, or the fan stops for extended periods while the strips carry the house, the defrost logic has drifted: a failing coil sensor, a board timing defrost on a schedule instead of demand, or a unit whose defrost terminates too late and restarts too eagerly. Each unnecessary cycle is a double charge, the heat given up reversing plus the strips covering for it, and hundreds of them per season is exactly how a bill grows a third.

The fix is diagnostic, not guesswork: a tech reads the defrost initiation and termination logic against the manufacturer's spec, checks the coil sensor, and verifies the strip staging during reversal. Sensor and board repairs run in the $180-$450 band on most platforms. Homeowner-side, the honest contribution is the log: a week of "steam at 7:10, 8:05, 8:50" on your phone is a diagnosis accelerant that saves real diagnostic time, and it costs nothing but attention.

Chapter 8

Cause 6: Ducts Warming the Wrong Rooms

If a fifth to a third of your heat pump's output never arrives in a room, the system is not inefficient, the delivery is. Duct leakage in the 20-30 percent range is normal for 1960s and 70s Metro Vancouver housing stock, where decades of additions, repurposed spaces and hand-cut takeoffs have left seams that were never sealed and boots that pulled loose from floor registers. Supply leaks into an attic or crawlspace are pure loss. Return leaks are sneakier: a return duct pulling cold crawlspace air forces the heat pump to raise that air instead of your room air, which reads on the bill exactly like efficiency loss.

The symptoms point at delivery, not the machine: rooms that never catch up, return air that smells like the crawlspace, dust that appears at registers in fine lines, and a blower that runs loud like it is working hard while far registers whisper. A static pressure test, part of a proper diagnostic, quantifies the restriction, and targeted sealing of accessible joints, boots, and the return drop typically runs $600-$2,000 depending on access, with whole-system balancing on the far end. The honest caveat: pricing is site-specific, and final numbers are confirmed in writing after someone has actually looked at where your ducts run.

Ducts are also the chapter where replacement math gets honest. Sealing a leaking delivery system under a healthy 8-year-old heat pump is a clear win. Sealing ducts under a 16-year-old unit with a tired compressor is a conversation about sequence, because the right order is equipment assessment first, envelope second, and both decisions belong in the same estimate, not two separate surprises. The energy upgrades guide covers the envelope half of that conversation.

Chapter 9

Cause 7: Furnace Habits on a Heat Pump Budget

The last cause is cultural. A generation of BC homeowners learned to heat with furnaces: crank it down at night, crank it up in the morning, let the big burner catch up in fifteen minutes. A heat pump punishes that reflex. A deep morning recovery, five degrees or more, is precisely the trigger for auxiliary strips, and one strip-driven recovery hour can erase the savings of the entire setback night. The efficient heat pump pattern is boring: set it, forget it, and let staged or smart recovery do the catching up gently, hours before you wake, at compressor speeds.

Three settings deserve a look this week. The EM HEAT position: it should be OFF in normal operation, and finding it ON is a free fix worth real money. The aux lockout threshold: on smart thermostats paired with cold-climate units, aux should be locked out until roughly -5°C to -10°C outdoor, depending on your unit's capacity curve, and a lockout set at +2°C turns every cool evening into a strip evening. And the recovery behavior: smart or adaptive recovery on, deep manual setpoints off, and a night setback of one to two degrees rather than five. These are settings, not repairs, and on some systems they are the whole problem.

A note for the two-zone and multi-head households: ductless heads running wall-set 24°C beside a central system set to 20°C will fight each other through the shared envelope, and the loser is usually the central unit's efficiency numbers. Coordinating setpoints across systems in the same house is free, takes ten minutes, and shows up on the next bill. Boring, again, but boring is what efficiency looks like from the thermostat.

Chapter 10

The Fix-Versus-Payback Math

Assume a typical detached Metro Vancouver home heating mainly with a heat pump, a winter usage around 8,000-12,000 kWh for heat, and a system running 25 percent rich at blended rates near 12-13 cents. That inefficiency costs roughly $250-$400 per heating season. Against that number, here is every fix in this guide, priced honestly, with the return stated plainly.

Fix Typical cost Seasonal saving if it's your cause Payback
Thermostat modes / lockouts corrected$0 (or $250-$500 for a smart stat)$100-$400Immediate
Filter change + hose wash of outdoor coil$15-$40, your labour$80-$250One season, often one month
Professional maintenance visit$149-$250$150-$350 stacked fixesUnder a year in most cases
Refrigerant leak search, repair, weigh-in$250-$900$150-$350/yr and compounding savings on compressor life2-4 seasons, plus avoided compressor failure
Defrost sensor / control repair$180-$450$100-$3001-3 seasons
Targeted duct sealing$600-$2,000, confirmed after inspection$200-$5002-5 seasons, plus comfort you can feel
Replace with cold-climate unit$6,500-$14,000 before up to $16,000 in stacked rebatesStep-change, not incrementalA different decision, with its own rebate math

Read the table the way a tech reads it: the first three rows are cheap enough to do on suspicion, and they resolve most high-bill complaints we see. The middle rows are diagnostic-dependent, worth doing when the measurements point at them. The last row is not a repair decision at all; it is a housing decision, and it deserves its own conversation with the rebate stack in front of it.

Chapter 11

The Efficiency Audit, and What We Measure

Everything in this guide converges on one visit. The $89 diagnostic, credited to any repair, measures your heat pump as a system: temperature rise across the indoor coil, which proves delivered capacity; pressures and subcooling against the charging chart, which proves the refrigerant side; amp draw on compressor and strips, which catches locked-on aux instantly; static pressure, which indicts or clears the ducts; and the defrost behaviour logged against outdoor conditions. The output is not a feeling about your system. It is numbers on a page: capacity as a percentage of nameplate, aux hours this season, and the two or three causes from this guide that apply to your house, ranked by payback.

Bring your BC Hydro usage history to the visit and the math gets sharper still, because a measured 30 percent capacity loss against a 25 percent usage creep tells a story neither number tells alone. And if the audit ends at the honest fork, replacement, the same crew that measured it will quote the replacement with the cold-climate performance standards we hold in the valley, rebates applied, old equipment hauled, and a commissioning report that shows the new unit's measured capacity. Efficiency is not a feature you buy once. It is a number you defend, and the defence starts with measuring.

Measure Before You Pay Another Rich Bill

Book the $89 efficiency diagnostic, credited to any repair. Capacity, charge, airflow, aux hours and defrost behaviour measured on your system, with fix-versus-payback math in writing. Zero obligation.

Quick answers

Frequently Asked Questions

Compare usage, not dollars. Pull two to three heating seasons from your BC Hydro account page and divide kWh by heating degree days for each month, which normalizes for weather. If kWh per degree-day is up 20 percent or more while your habits and thermostat settings are unchanged, the machine is working harder to deliver the same heat, and that is efficiency loss, not rates. A single mild winter can hide a failing system, which is why the degree-day math beats eyeballing the bill total.
Auxiliary strips are resistance heaters: one kWh in, roughly 3,412 BTU out, always. Your heat pump moves heat instead of making it, so at a COP of 2.5 to 3.5 each kWh buys two and a half to three and a half times more heat. When strips carry the load, every hour of heat costs roughly three times what the compressor would have paid for the same warmth. Worse, strips often run quietly alongside the compressor for weeks before anyone notices, which is why we treat aux heat hours as the first number to check on any high-bill complaint.
Yes, and by more than people expect. A condenser coil fouled with cottonwood seed, lawn clippings, or coastal grime cannot move heat, so capacity drops and runtime climbs, typically 10 to 20 percent more electricity for the same heat. In heating mode a matted coil also ices sooner and defrosts longer. The fix is a garden-hose wash twice a year, May and September, fifteen minutes each, power off at the disconnect first. It is the highest-return maintenance task on the machine.
Any recurring need for refrigerant is a leak, not a maintenance item, and even 10 to 15 percent undercharge measurably drops capacity and COP while raising compressor strain. Signs include longer runtimes, weaker supply air on cold days, frosting on the outdoor coil in odd patterns, and a system that used to hold temperature at -5°C that now needs strips. Sealed-system work is certified-technician-only territory in BC; a proper fix is a leak search, repair, and a weighed-in charge to nameplate, typically $250-$900 depending on access and refrigerant type.
Only modestly, and never in a deep setback. A heat pump recovering from a 4°C setback on a cold morning will frequently trigger auxiliary strips to catch up, and one hour of strip recovery can erase the savings of eight quiet setback hours. The efficient pattern is one or two degrees at night with a smart thermostat that learns staged recovery, or simply set-and-forget. In BC's climate, consistency beats setback for heat pumps, which is the opposite of the furnace advice most of us grew up with.
When the efficiency loss is architectural: a 15-plus-year-old unit with a worn compressor and a refrigerant that has been topped up twice, or ducts so leaky that a third of your heat warms an attic. The math works when repair quotes stack toward $1,000 or more on equipment near end of life, especially with CleanBC and utility rebates up to $16,000 on qualifying cold-climate units. A repair should buy years, not months. If it buys months, replacement is the cheaper habit.
Related services

Services From This Guide

Licensed crews, flat-rate pricing and 24/7 emergency response across the twelve Metro Vancouver cities we serve, from Vancouver and Burnaby through Surrey, Richmond and New Westminster out to Maple Ridge and Abbotsford.

Written by the BC Home Service Team

We audit heat pump performance across Metro Vancouver year-round, from salt-air coil cleanings in Richmond to aux-heat lockout hunts in the Fraser Valley cold pockets. Red Seal certified, licensed gas fitters, $2M insured, 12,000+ jobs since 2010. This guide is the measurement-first approach we bring to every high-bill complaint, written down so you can run the first half yourself. To turn these numbers into a flat-rate quote, see heat pump repair in Burnaby — same-day across the city.

More about our team →
Free Estimate

Get the Efficiency Audit Before You Pay Another Surprise Bill

Book the $89 diagnostic, credited to any repair, and we will measure what your heat pump is actually delivering: capacity, charge, airflow, aux heat hours and defrost behaviour, with the fix-versus-payback math in writing. Zero obligation. If you would rather hand this to a pro, our heat pump services pages cover Metro Vancouver.

Heat pump failing in the cold?

Emergency crews answer 24/7 with live dispatch and a flat $150 after-hours premium posted in advance. We diagnose at $89, credited to the repair, and we tell you honestly when the fix is a filter and when it is a compressor.

Call 604-615-2212 WhatsApp Us
Manual J right-sizing on every quote, never oversized
10-year parts warranties registered for you
Financing from 7.99% with approved credit
24/7 emergency line, average 45-minute response
Call Now Free Quote